Elon Musk and Trump win fight to keep DOGE’s work secret

Hemlocke

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,196
Is your first inclination always to roll over and go belly up?
I'm a fucking combat veteran, so not even close. I'm not the one who has rolled over and showed my belly, Congress is. I'm just saying there is no enforcement mechanism anymore for the courts even if they find in favor of plaintiffs because the DOJ has been neutered.
 
Upvote
33 (33 / 0)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

Marakai

Ars Scholae Palatinae
722
Subscriptor++
Hey man, I was just born here 40 years ago. I voted for Harris. If you have ideas on how I can protest in the biggest police state in the world, in a way that will cause anything to change, while also not losing my home, job, health insurance, family...I'm all ears!
And there's the rub, innit?

There used to be a quip "Germans won't have a revolution and occupy the train stations, without buying a ticket".

Americans won't have a revolution until they have their mortgage paid off, it seems.

IOW, as long as for the average American today is pretty much the same rat race as tomorrow, they won't take to the streets. And by the time it's become too bad, it will be too late (if it isn't already, which personally I believe).

Let me repeat: I'm not blaming you or others of the American "precariat". Most people aren't cut out to become Che Guevara or whoever, and run a guerilla war from the mountains and woods.

That said, we're not even seeing marches like in the the 60s and 70s. That is pretty pathetic.
 
Upvote
32 (32 / 0)

Jackattak

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
6,521
Subscriptor++
Hey man, I was just born here 40 years ago. I voted for Harris. If you have ideas on how I can protest in the biggest police state in the world, in a way that will cause anything to change, while also not losing my home, job, health insurance, family...I'm all ears!
1) buy local

2) don’t buy swastikars

3) be really sweet and lead with love with everything you do

I’m probably forgetting some other forms of non violent and even passive protest. Any and/or all of these are effective means and have real benefit.
 
Upvote
9 (10 / -1)

Jackattak

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
6,521
Subscriptor++
You have disgruntled veterans and fired top military officers. You have a power that's concentrated in Washington DC. You have an almost unlimited amount of weapons and ammos.

If South Koreans, Turks, Greeks, Georgians and Serbians can take to the streets by the hundreds of thousands, surely you can too.

So don't tell us you can't get a couple millions of citizens to wipe out this entire administration if need be.
“Man, they got stuff that can blow out our backs.

From where they stay at.”

- Andre Benjamin aka Andre 3000
 
Upvote
2 (4 / -2)

Danathar

Ars Praefectus
4,247
Subscriptor
1) buy local

2) don’t buy swastikars

3) be really sweet and lead with love with everything you do

I’m probably forgetting some other forms of non violent and even passive protest. Any and/or all of these are effective means and have real benefit.
The way of the bodhisattva is worth following
 
Upvote
1 (3 / -2)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
I'm a fucking combat veteran, so not even close. I'm not the one who has rolled over and showed my belly, Congress is. I'm just saying there is no enforcement mechanism anymore for the courts even if they find in favor of plaintiffs because the DOJ has been neutered.
As I said above, it really depends on what the marshals do. We havent had that tested yet, we’ll get our answer one way or the other eventually, let’s hope the answer is “follow the constitution, their oaths, and the court’s orders”
 
Upvote
6 (6 / 0)
It’s hard to go a day without hearing some action from this president and his cults members that doesn’t make your blood boil.
I'm self medicating with a double strength cocktail today.

Though it is making it hard to refrain from typing things like I hope the dumbass "we" elected President chokes on his well done steak with ketchup.
 
Upvote
9 (10 / -1)
He can only really use that to prevent criminal investigations on his own personal actions if they can be considered to be under the umbrella of being an "official act."

Other members of his admin aren't protected.
Other members of his admin are counting on the pardons he promised. Why do you think he pardoned all those Jan6 criminals?

The supreme court may have ended democracy in the US by creating a president who is above the law and can also pardon any criminal working for him. How exactly do you stop criminal activity in the administration if you've defined their innocence as being up to a single, powerful, legally immune person?
 
Upvote
23 (23 / 0)

David Mayer

Wise, Aged Ars Veteran
947
Other members of his admin are counting on the pardons he promised. Why do you think he pardoned all those Jan6 criminals?

The supreme court may have ended democracy in the US by creating a president who is above the law and can also pardon any criminal working for him. How exactly do you stop criminal activity in the administration if you've defined their innocence as being up to a single, powerful, legally immune person?
Answering that question honestly is probably bannable and likely to get you into trouble far beyond a ban.
 
Upvote
19 (20 / -1)
Other members of his admin are counting on the pardons he promised. Why do you think he pardoned all those Jan6 criminals?

The supreme court may have ended democracy in the US by creating a president who is above the law and can also pardon any criminal working for him. How exactly do you stop criminal activity in the administration if you've defined their innocence as being up to a single, powerful, legally immune person?
I mean, the theoretical answer is either impeachment and removal or the cabinet invoking the 25th, but given congress has decided its entire job is to deepthroat Trump’s boots* and the cabinet is, as a result, full of sycophants, the only real answer at the moment is “let’s hope Trump finally eats one too many cheeseburgers and keels over from a massive cardiac arrest”.

McDonald’s, please up the fat content of your burgers, the country is counting on you

*If the democrats somehow massively overperform in 2026 and get 2/3s in both houses they can impeach and remove Trump
 
Upvote
16 (16 / 0)

steelcobra

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
9,384
I mean, the theoretical answer is either impeachment and removal or the cabinet invoking the 25th, but given congress has decided its entire job is to deepthroat Trump’s boots* and the cabinet is, as a result, full of sycophants, the only real answer at the moment is “let’s hope Trump finally eats one too many cheeseburgers and keels over from a massive cardiac arrest”.

McDonald’s, please up the fat content of your burgers, the country is counting on you

*If the democrats somehow massively overperform in 2026 and get 2/3s in both houses they can impeach and remove Trump
The problem with that tactic is that JD Vance becomes president.
 
Upvote
20 (20 / 0)

Hmnhntr

Ars Scholae Palatinae
2,272
And if you insist that the rape victim analogy. You have to stretch it to absolute absurdity to make it even remotely comparable:

Note, I strongly recommend anyone with trauma or triggers related even tangentially to rape stop reading now.

A woman is at a party, with a bunch of male and female friends she trusts. She is completely sober, she is talking to a man she knows has raped someone before, and the man says, just so you know, I want to rape you, and plan on doing so at midnight. The woman then says "please don't rape me". She also gets some of her friends to politely ask the rapist not to rape her. At midnight she is raped in front of all her friends.

Is the woman to blame? Absolutely not! Should the woman and her friends have done more to prevent the rape? Fucking yes!

Right now, we are at the point where the rapist is actively raping the woman, (immigrants being held, tortured, and deported without due process), he has stated he plans on raping other people (attaching the rights of LGBT people) and you suspect that he might start murdering people (think either large scale war, gas chambers, or both). Right now, the friend group is still asking nicely for the rapist to stop.

And right now, you are one of the friends, watching the rape happen right in front of you, arguing about who is responsible. And I'm a friend in another city, texting you asking you to PLEASE FUCKING DO SOMETHING FOR MY FRIEND!
You really are an asshole, you know that? What was I supposed to do? Force other people to vote how I wanted? March to the polls with a gun and scare off anyone voting for Trump? Kidnap a politician? Assassinate Trump? What, exactly, could and should I, as an average person, have done to change the outcome of that election?

You know, I actually have things on the line, here. Two of my best friends are trans. My brother is autistic. My whole family is Hispanic. Do you have any stake in this? It's easy to just shout at other people to do something when you're not the one there. If it's so important, if you're basically watching someone get raped, why don't you do something, too? Why aren't you willing to drop everything, fly to the States, and start protesting? Is your inconvenience somehow an excuse? Is that too much to ask? After all, anyone who isn't doing literally everything they can is just an asshole watching their friend get raped, right? Or does that magically not apply to you? Is it too much to ask you to upend your life, put your welfare on the line? Is there not enough you could realistically do to help?
 
Upvote
22 (26 / -4)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

jey9

Ars Tribunus Militum
1,572
Subscriptor++
It's okay to accede to bullies, I guess. Or you could engage with your Congressional reps and let them know how you, as a veteran feel about their inaction. I'll just have to take your word for what a fighter you are despite your Paxton-esque "Game Over" whimpering.
The problem is that you're seeking a democratic solution to a problem that's outside of our Democracy.

The levers that congress people have to pull to stop Trump are completely broken, as long as he doesn't acknowledge them. Those levers had an effect on past presidents because those presidents respected the rule of law and our democratic institutions. None of that applies when you have a true fascist like Trump.

We are no longer operating in a functional democracy, and complaining about congress people is just an answer to yesterday's problems.
 
Upvote
16 (17 / -1)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
I mean, the theoretical answer is either impeachment and removal or the cabinet invoking the 25th, but given congress has decided its entire job is to deepthroat Trump’s boots* and the cabinet is, as a result, full of sycophants, the only real answer at the moment is “let’s hope Trump finally eats one too many cheeseburgers and keels over from a massive cardiac arrest”.

McDonald’s, please up the fat content of your burgers, the country is counting on you

*If the democrats somehow massively overperform in 2026 and get 2/3s in both houses they can impeach and remove Trump
Assuming we have elections in 2026, and that they're not rigged.
 
Upvote
6 (6 / 0)

PsychoArs

Ars Scholae Palatinae
713
Subscriptor
1) buy local

2) don’t buy swastikars

3) be really sweet and lead with love with everything you do

I’m probably forgetting some other forms of non violent and even passive protest. Any and/or all of these are effective means and have real benefit.
Don't do that. Buy Canadian. <Grin>

As for number 3... I'm sorry but the current administration has literally declared "woke ideology" to be so horrendous it needs to be excised from the country.

Woke ideology is - basically - "be nice". Someone wants you to use G'PLURP and B-B-BPUTU as their pronouns? Sure. Doesn't hurt anyone. Someone feels like God put a male soul in a female body? Sure. He (or She, or G'plurp) works in mysterious ways, right? People with darker skin don't get opportunities because of light-skin-bias and someone wants to eliminate that bias? Sure. When you need to borrow a neighbor's pickup truck it doesn't matter if he's black or white... he's just a dude with a truck.

Woke isn't "encourage people to transition" or "give all the gay black ladies the jobs while cutting off white dudes' balls". It's just... stop... being... assholes.

Well, this crew thinks being an asshole is a virtue, and you really, really can't fight that with being nice. Teach their kids that being nice is the better path, but kick the adult's asses because that's all they are willing to understand.
 
Upvote
19 (19 / 0)

graylshaped

Ars Legatus Legionis
61,409
Subscriptor++
The problem is that you're seeking a democratic solution to a problem that's outside of our Democracy.
I don’t consider choosing to abandon democratic principles a path to sustaining those principles.

Nor, to curtail further encouragement to hastily throw the baby out with the bath, should naivety prevent contingency plans.

Jeebus. Y’all sound like one of Trump’s executive orders insisting shortcuts are the only way to get things done.
 
Upvote
4 (6 / -2)

ewelch

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
9,178
Subscriptor++
Can't trump literally point to TRUMP v. UNITED STATES and the John Roberts Supreme Court decision that gives him unfettered power to do whatever he wants during his administration without fear of the pesky law getting in the way?
No, he just can't be prosecuted for it.
 
Upvote
0 (0 / 0)

jtwrenn

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,169
Can't trump literally point to TRUMP v. UNITED STATES and the John Roberts Supreme Court decision that gives him unfettered power to do whatever he wants during his administration without fear of the pesky law getting in the way?
He could just change what he is doing over and over again or delete info they request and move it. Technically he can't be thrown in jail for doing anything supposedly part of the job of president so that means even if they push him to stop he could just shift it to doge 2 say it is different then start it all over again. The only way to stop him would be impeachment.

It really means we are totally f'ed in the A until the midterms and if we don't get back the house and some of the senate it's gonna be a horrible mess. Until then all we can do is delay and the dems in congress need to realize that and fight like hell to delay. Right now they are still playing nice with a dictator and that pivot has to happen fast or we may be f'd in the A permanently.
 
Upvote
3 (4 / -1)

PaulWTAMU

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,479
Subscriptor
It's okay to accede to bullies, I guess. Or you could engage with your Congressional reps and let them know how you, as a veteran feel about their inaction. I'll just have to take your word for what a fighter you are despite your Paxton-esque "Game Over" whimpering.
what a goddamn thoughtless post.

We do not know what that poster has done re: contacting reps. God knows I'm pretty sure Ted Cruz and Cornyn promptly delete my emails without bothering to open them.

Seriously, what the fuck do you think we ought to be doing? Shit that'll get us shot or arrested ? And if someone here was risking that would it be smart to post it here on a public forum?
 
Upvote
16 (16 / 0)

graylshaped

Ars Legatus Legionis
61,409
Subscriptor++
what a goddamn thoughtless post.

We do not know what that poster has done re: contacting reps. God knows I'm pretty sure Ted Cruz and Cornyn promptly delete my emails without bothering to open them.

Seriously, what the fuck do you think we ought to be doing? Shit that'll get us shot or arrested ? And if someone here was risking that would it be smart to post it here on a public forum?
Easy, hoss. Just validating armchair warrior status. You're good to go.

Please forgive any lack of patience with petulant whining I may have displayed.
 
Upvote
-14 (3 / -17)

mozbo

Ars Tribunus Militum
1,845
That said, we're not even seeing marches like in the the 60s and 70s. That is pretty pathetic.
There have been lots of marches. Search for anti-trump rally and you'll get plenty of hits. Reporting on them has been shamefully thin, especially compared to the 60s / 70s. The major media outlets often act like caved-in wimps, bent on preserving "access". That's not a new thing. The anti-Iraq war protests were big. The BLM protests were massive. Media coverage was ... underwhelming.

I do agree the size is smaller. For now. I suspect that's partly because of who is afraid of police violence. In the 60s/70s, cop violence was usually targeted at PoC and visibly obvious counter-culture types. Now? Totally different story. A lot more people would feel threatened by cops at a protest - even your average white liberal mom'n'pop. That's going to keep people home ... until their desperation starts outweighing their fear.
 
Upvote
18 (20 / -2)

mozbo

Ars Tribunus Militum
1,845
The problem with that tactic is that JD Vance becomes president.
They'd have to impeach and remove Vance & Trump at the same time.

But ... we've seen that movie. Agnew (Vance) resigns, Nixon (Trump) appoints a "we have to move forward" guy as VP (Ford).

The president being able to freely appoint anyone he wants as new VP is a huge loophole. It should require consent of the House and Senate.
 
Upvote
9 (10 / -1)

Madestjohn

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
6,550
There have been lots of marches. Search for anti-trump rally and you'll get plenty of hits. Reporting on them has been shamefully thin, especially compared to the 60s / 70s. The major media outlets often act like caved-in wimps, bent on preserving "access". That's not a new thing. The anti-Iraq war protests were big. The BLM protests were massive. Media coverage was ... underwhelming.

I do agree the size is smaller. For now. I suspect that's partly because of who is afraid of police violence. In the 60s/70s, cop violence was usually targeted at PoC and visibly obvious counter-culture types. Now? Totally different story. A lot more people would feel threatened by cops at a protest - even your average white liberal mom'n'pop. That's going to keep people home ... until their desperation starts outweighing their fear.
.. I don’t see that fear diminishing


View: https://youtu.be/PuFIs7OkzYY?si=1fptWIROdcoaNHut
 
Upvote
17 (17 / 0)