Starlink profit growing rapidly as it faces a moment of promise and peril

Post content hidden for low score. Show…
If you willingly* support spacex, you support musk.

if you support musk, you support evil.

It's quite frankly that simple.


edited to add "willingly" because the choice between no internet at all or starlink isn't really a choice at all for the individual in the modern world. But being a cheerleader for spacex is beyond the pale at this point, IMO.
 
Last edited:
Upvote
178 (326 / -148)

Keith Tanner

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,084
The contract, signed in November, was intended to provide high-speed Internet to 15,000 eligible homes and businesses in rural, remote and northern communities by June of this year. Musk is "part of the Trump team that wants to destroy families, incomes, destroy businesses," Ford said at a news conference Monday. "He wants to take food off the table of people—hard-working people—and I'm not going to tolerate it."

Cancelling a government contract with a company because you disagree with their owner's politics seems no better legally than entering into a government contract with a company because you agree with their owner's politics.

It will be interesting to see if such a decision survives judicial review.
Welcome to a trade war. It's politically inadvisable for the Canadian government to do business with US corporations right now, especially those who are tied to Musk. Since Ford is a politician, he's doing the right thing in the eyes of his constituents.
 
Upvote
359 (385 / -26)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
As someone who has consistently supported SpaceX, was excited about Starlink, and even got yelled at right here for suggesting we could give Elon the benefit of the doubt regarding his Nazi solutes, **** him and his businesses. He is illegally accessing government computer systems, illegally obstructing payments of government contracts, illegally attempting to shut down an entire federal agency, and is doing god only knowns what else.

He should be arrested and SpaceX should be seized in the interest of national security.
 
Upvote
340 (426 / -86)
As someone who has consistently supported SpaceX, was excited about Starlink, and even got yelled at right here for suggesting we could give Elon the benefit of the doubt regarding his Nazi solutes, **** him and his businesses. He is illegally accessing government computer systems, illegally obstructing payments of government contracts, illegally attempting to shut down an entire federal agency, and is doing god only knowns what else.

He should be arrested and SpaceX should be seized in the interest of national security.

It's appalling
He has no business doing any of these blatantly illegal acts
 
Upvote
172 (214 / -42)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

stormcrash

Ars Tribunus Angusticlavius
8,993
If you're reading the comments, I'd pack up here.

Those top two perfectly describe where this is about to go.

Personally I have a mixture of awe and despair.
Now is the time for self sacrifice and to put the needs of humanity and our country above personal interests
 
Upvote
68 (97 / -29)
Cancelling a government contract with a company because you disagree with their owner's politics seems no better legally than entering into a government contract with a company because you agree with their owner's politics.
Sure, if you define "politics" as "desire to dismantle the US government, completely tank the economy and replace the dollar with Bitcoin," sure.

You think you're correct because your logic is sound. And your logic IS sound but it's based on a false premise: the notion that what Elon is doing is "just politics." It isn't. You're acting like it's a disagreement over simple matters of how to implement some economy policy. It isn't "just politics" but you are pretending that it is.

It's like if you had an office where one guy kept saying, "I'm gonna bring a gun one day and murder some of my coworkers." And then they do nothing about it, but when other employees are told to sit next to him, they say, "I don't want to sit next to him he might kill me!" And then HR goes, "oh grow up you shouldn't not sit next to a coworker because of political differences."

It is a completely appropriate analogy given that Musk literally said BEFORE the election that he planned to tank the economy if Trump won.

Do not make the mistake of confusing a logically sound argument with one that is actually true.
 
Upvote
274 (316 / -42)

tlhIngan

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,306
Subscriptor++
I suspect Starlink will soon see a bunch of additional taxes in non-US countries (including Canada) over the tariffs. The big problem for Starlink now is that Starlink relies on ground stations in other countries, and pissing them off isn't going to make life any easier.

That's how Brazil got the concessions it did on Starlink regarding X - because Brazil could seize Starlink assets in Brazil, which include a ground station, which would disable Starlink completely over the area.
 
Upvote
152 (162 / -10)
The contract, signed in November, was intended to provide high-speed Internet to 15,000 eligible homes and businesses in rural, remote and northern communities by June of this year. Musk is "part of the Trump team that wants to destroy families, incomes, destroy businesses," Ford said at a news conference Monday. "He wants to take food off the table of people—hard-working people—and I'm not going to tolerate it."

Cancelling a government contract with a company because you disagree with their owner's politics seems no better legally than entering into a government contract with a company because you agree with their owner's politics.

It will be interesting to see if such a decision survives judicial review.
And that's why "normal" countries don't put CEOs in government, because legislation and policy doesn't mix with founder mode. Even better, government and policymakers are not allowed to have business interests or receive contributions of any kind. Because remember... they're all supposed to be working for the people who elect them. Not the corps with the biggest lobby budget.
 
Upvote
209 (223 / -14)

BananaBonanza

Ars Scholae Palatinae
808
Subscriptor
The key takeaway I want everybody to walk away with is, if SpaceX was building the Starlink system to pay for a Mars colony, we've got evidence that the company will generate the type of free cash flows from the business that could pay for said endeavor

Yes, we know what awesome things Musk could use his money for. We also know what he has actually used his money for.
 
Upvote
178 (198 / -20)

LDA 6502

Ars Scholae Palatinae
1,254
Welcome to a trade war. It's politically inadvisable for the Canadian government to do business with US corporations right now, especially those who are tied to Musk. Since Ford is a politician, he's doing the right thing in the eyes of his constituents.
A trade war, for now. Trump's expansionist aspirations may kick tensions up a notch or three in the coming years. Might be wise to hope for the best, but prepare for the worst.
 
Upvote
44 (56 / -12)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
If you support spacex, you support musk.

if you support musk, you support evil.

It's quite frankly that simple.
Yep. I used to be a fan of SpaceX but now it doesn't matter. If the end of SpaceX means Musk loses power, it's a good thing.

Anything that harms Musk's companies is good for the planet at this point.

Shiny rockets and going to Mars isn't worth it if it's under technofascist rule. Werner von Braun believed that conquering space was the most important thing ever, eclipsing what he viewed as "politics." Would the Third Cosmic Reich have been worth it, just to get us into space?

Fuck no. It's 2025 and new rocket companies are springing up left and right, firing completely new designs for motors that don't even blow up on the first attempt.

Rockets are, essentially, a solved problem. Now it's about engineering the vehicles and infrastructure at scale. Anyone can do this.

Building into space has a clear and straightforward scientific and engineering path. Keeping a republic is far, far, FAR harder.
 
Upvote
232 (277 / -45)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…

Sajuuk

Ars Legatus Legionis
10,885
Subscriptor++
That's sort of happened but in the backwards way. Musk is functionally president / the US government now.
Yeah, run government like a business!

Wait, what do you mean my country is now an autocracy run by fiat from the top down and nobody cares about the human widgets at the bottom. Ohno.
 
Upvote
147 (156 / -9)
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
Post content hidden for low score. Show…
if you vote lesser evil, you support evil. It's that simple.

I can only get internet service from Starlink because decades of lesser-evil voting resulted in a government that had no interest in ensuring that broadband funding recipients actually use the money to provide service.

I have no choice but to support SpaceX, therefor I am evil.
Current plans to fund broadband in my area are focused on giving AT&T funding to upgrade AT&T's network, and are not focused on bringing wireline service to areas where there are no wireline options.

More than likely, I will always be beholden to Starlink for access to the internet.


I think you're the exception that proves the rule (which is a really bizarre saying/concept). Nobody rational is gonna be mad at someone in that situation.

I was originally talking more about emotional support/leghumping than financial support, to be honest.
 
Upvote
6 (34 / -28)

Keith Tanner

Ars Tribunus Militum
2,084
I'm not questioning if it is good politics - I'm questioning if the courts will determine it's legal.

To put it another way, would you expect the courts to allow a future right wing Canadian administration to cancel contracts with companies they deemed too liberal?
Without looking at the contract, it's hard to say if it's strictly legal but I'll bet it'll get through any review. This is more that just "not liking politics", the US has declared economic war on Canada and Musk is basically part of the government. Note that you won't be able to buy US beer, liquor or wine in Ontario next week either. There's a billion dollars (Canadian) of sales that just disappeared.
 
Upvote
120 (122 / -2)