Ars Technica logo. Serving the PC enthusiast for over 5x10-2 centuries  

Subscribe to Ars Technica!

Have news? Send it in.

 
Ars Guides.
  Buyer's Guide
  How-To's & Tweaks
  Product Reviews
  Ars Shopping Engine

Technopaedia.
  Technical Blackpapers
  CPU Theory & Praxis
  Ars OpenForum
  Search Ars

Columnar Edifice.
  Wankerdesk
  AskArs!
  Diary of a Geek
  Game.Ars Report   Mac.Ars takes on...
  Linux.Ars

Site Info.
  Subscribe to Ars
  Ars Merchandise
  Who We Ars
  Advertising
  Links



Virtual machine shootout: VMware vs. Virtual PC

   by Adam Baratz

 

Microsoft Virtual PC 2004

Virtual PC was originally developed for Mac OS by Connectix (the Mac version is still available which emulates rather than virtualizes an x86 computer). Microsoft bought the software from them, spruced it up, and has repackaged it as Microsoft Virtual PC 2004.

Since it is a Microsoft product, the most exotic OS it officially supports is OS/2. Microsoft has stated that they are not opposed to their software being using with other operating systems, however they're considered to be "third-party products." If you have trouble getting someone else's OS to run with Virtual PC, they will direct you to the operating system developer for support. This is not to say other operating systems won't run at all. There is significant documentation available to demonstrate that getting unsupported operating systems to run isn't that big a deal.

Virtual PC running XPAs this wouldn't be a proper Ars review without a little messing around, I had to see if I could at least get Linux working. I tried both Fedora Core 2 and Red Hat 9. Fedora installed easily, but caused Virtual PC to freeze when it tried to reboot. I was eventually able to kill the process, but it took a lot of coercion. The OS would boot, but all commands resulted in segfaulting.

Red Hat 9 froze in the same fashion after installation; this time I had to reboot my computer to actually get rid of the stuck process. Afterwards, however, I had a functional Linux installation. I only tested GNOME, but presumably other configurations of X Windows also work. Unfortunately, since Linux isn't officially supported, you can't enable pointer integration or file sharing.

The biggest draw to Virtual PC is its ease of use. A wizard guides you through setting up your virtual machines. The options aren't very detailed: you specify the OS you intend to use (other is an option for the more adventurous), the amount of memory to allocate, and the location for the virtual hard drive.

Most flexibility issues seem to be there to make the program simpler to use. As a result, getting from setting up Virtual PC to a working OS installation is painless. Since there are so few options to act as stumbling blocks, it's very easy to get your VM working.

A consequence of this ease of use is fairly limited customizability through the GUI. About the most fine-tuning you can do is changing the amount of memory to allocate. You can only use three hard drives. You can't add optical drives, even if you just want to use ISOs. These limitations aren't inconveniences for everyone, but they should be noted if they'll cause problems in your working environment.

However, it is possible to further tweak VPC by editing the .vmc file installed (by default) in \My Documents\My Virtual Machines. The .vmc file is actually an XML preference file for Virtual PC. Open it up in your favorite text editor and you can do things like edit the MAC address of your network adapter and make other tweaks not possible via the program itself.

Despite the fixed hardware, what you have to work with isn't that limited. Virtual PC supports as much memory as you can throw at it, three hard drives, an optical drive, a floppy drive, serial and parallel ports, four network adapters, and sound (Sound Blaster-compatible). Network adapters can be bridged, only connected to the host, or setup to share the host's connection with NAT. You can connect a named pipe or a text file on the host to either of the two possible serial ports if you want a little more control. An S3 Trio64 is the emulated video card. SCSI support is limited: Virtual PC can use SCSI hard drives, but it cannot pass through other devices. Thus, while a SCSI hard drive will show up to the VM as an IDE drive, you will not be able to connect, say, a SCSI tape drive to VPC.

The main interface for Virtual PC is its console window. It contains a listing of the virtual machines you're currently using (though you can store virtual machines on your computer and leave them unlisted). When VM is running, it shows an active thumbnail of its display.


Console with inactive VM


Console with active VM

Each virtual machine receives its own window. A status bar displays hard drive, CD, and network access. You can pause and hibernate VMs and resume activity later. Virtual PC also has a feature called undo disks. They store changes made to your virtual HD in separate files. If something catastrophic happens, you can revert to the disk's last saved state; otherwise you can commit the changes.

VM Additions support is very good. Drivers are available for all flavors of Windows 9x, NT 4.0 SP6, 2000, XP, OS/2 Warp 4, and even DOS. I didn't encounter any problems with Windows 2000 or XP. The most notable features added are file sharing, pointer integration, and dynamic display resizing. Resizing the VM window or switching to fullscreen mode automatically adjusts the resolution of the VM to fill the new space. Very helpful.

If you decide to use a VM to play DOS games, Virtual PC has a number of very desirable features. Sound works instantly. No special setup was needed for sound in Virtual PC; all games tested autodetected it without a hitch. File sharing also makes getting files into DOS much easier.

While some users may find fault with the fixed hardware support and limited OS compatibility, Virtual PC is an extremely-polished program that should meet most peoples' needs.

Next: VMware Workstation 4.5

 


Dual 2.5GHz Power Mac G5 review

The Sims 2 review

Pipelining: an overview (Part II)

System Guide: September edition

Pipelining: an overview (Part I)

Chris Sawyer's Locomotion review

Multicore, dual-core, and the future of Intel

System Guide: gaming boxes

TrackIR3 Pro review

Doom 3: the review

PowerPC on Apple: An Architectural History, Part I

Virtual machine shootout: Virtual PC vs. VMware

The Pentium: An Architectural History � Part II

Joint Operations: Typhoon Rising game review

AirPort Express review

The Pentium: An Architectural History � Part I

The Ars guide to PCI Express

Beyond Divinity game review

The future of Prescott

Interview with Mozilla.org's Scott Collins

Thief: Deadly Shadows game review

USB 2.0 Hi-Speed Flash drive review

A closer look at Intel's processor numbers and 2004 road map

Far Cry game review

Dell Latitude D800 laptop review

HP Compaq nc6000 laptop review

Hitman: Contracts game review

Deploying a small business Windows 2003 network

Alternative AIM clients for Windows

Inside GNOME 2.6

/etc

OpenForum

Distributed Computing

Take the Poll Technica

FAQ: Celeron overclocking

 

Copyright © 1998-2004 Ars Technica, LLC